The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) continues to evolve, but one trend remains constant: the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) is aggressively enforcing compliance failures. In the modern, digitized healthcare environment, violations are rarely small. They often lead to massive security breaches, multi-million dollar settlements, and required corrective action plans that can take years to complete.
OCR enforcement actions highlight a clear message: systemic failures in proactive security measures and disregard for patient rights are the most costly mistakes.
The Top 10 HIPAA Violations
1. Failure to Conduct an Accurate and Thorough Risk Analysis
This is arguably the single most fined violation under the HIPAA Security Rule and the foundation of virtually all other security failures.
A Risk Analysis (or Risk Assessment) is the mandatory process of identifying where all your electronic Protected Health Information (ePHI) exists, what threats it faces, and what safeguards you must implement to protect it. Many organizations conduct a superficial analysis or none at all, leaving them blind to critical vulnerabilities.
- The Mandate: Required under 45 CFR § 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A).
- Prevention: Conduct an annual, comprehensive, organization-wide Risk Analysis that addresses the Security Rule’s Administrative, Physical, and Technical safeguards. This analysis must be meticulously documented.
- Government Resource: Review the official HHS Guidance on Risk Analysis.
2. Impermissible Use and Disclosure of PHI
This is the single most frequent category of HIPAA complaint received by the OCR, covering any time Protected Health Information (PHI) is used or shared without a reason permitted by the HIPAA Privacy Rule.
This broad violation covers everything from discussing a patient in a public hallway to sending PHI via unsecure email.
- The Mandate: The Privacy Rule (45 CFR § 164.502).
- Prevention: Implement strict, documented policies for handling PHI. Train employees extensively on what constitutes Treatment, Payment, or Healthcare Operations (TPO) and when patient authorization is required. Use secure, encrypted channels for all electronic communication of PHI.
3. Denying Patient Right of Access (Delayed or Withheld Records)
The HIPAA Right of Access Initiative has been a major OCR enforcement priority since 2019, resulting in dozens of fines. Patients have the right to receive a copy of their medical records in the format of their choice, and Covered Entities often fail to meet the legal deadline (generally 30 days).
- The Mandate: The Privacy Rule (45 CFR § 164.524).
- Prevention: Establish a clear, written policy for fulfilling record requests. Appoint a dedicated compliance officer to track deadlines. Do not withhold records due to unpaid bills or complicated procedures.
- Government Resource: See the full details of your obligations in the HHS Individual’s Right to Access Guide.
4. Failure to Enter into a Business Associate Agreement (BAA)
Your liability extends to the vendors you use. Any third-party vendor (a Business Associate) that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI on your behalf must have a signed Business Associate Agreement (BAA) in place with your organization. Failing to secure a BAA before disclosing PHI is an immediate violation and breach.
- The Mandate: The Privacy and Security Rules (45 CFR § 164.308(b) and 45 CFR § 164.502(e)).
- Prevention: Implement a rigorous Vendor Management Program. Do not send or allow a vendor to access PHI until a BAA is signed. Understand that under the Common Agency Provision, their breach is your breach.
- Total HIPAA Resource: Download a Free BAA Template to ensure your contracts are compliant.
5. Hacking, Ransomware, and Malware Attacks
While hacking itself is a crime, the violation comes from the inadequate security measures that allowed the attack to succeed. Ransomware and large-scale phishing attacks are the leading causes of massive data breaches today.
- The Mandate: Security Management Process (45 CFR § 164.308(a)(1)).
- Prevention:
- Implement long passwords (15 Characters or more)
- Require Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) on all systems, especially email and remote access.
- Consider using Passkeys for systems that allow it.
- Patch software vulnerabilities immediately.
- Use robust anti-malware and network monitoring tools.
- Conduct continuous Security Awareness Training to build a human firewall against phishing and social engineering.
6. Inadequate Security Safeguards (Lack of Encryption)
The theft or loss of unencrypted laptops, smartphones, and USB drives remains a significant source of violations. While encryption is “addressable” under the Security Rule, OCR consistently recommends it as the “best defense.” Breaches involving encrypted data are generally not reportable under the Breach Notification Rule.
- The Mandate: Security Rule Technical Safeguards (45 CFR § 164.312).
- Prevention: Mandate full disk encryption for all devices (laptops, desktops, mobile phones, and backups) that store ePHI. Implement strong access controls, including automatic logoff and unique user IDs.
7. Unauthorized Employee Access (“Snooping”)
This violation occurs when a workforce member accesses a patient record without a legitimate reason (e.g., family member, celebrity, co-worker). This falls under the Impermissible Disclosure umbrella but is distinguished by the internal nature of the violation.
- The Mandate: Workforce Security (45 CFR § 164.308(a)(3)).
- Prevention: Enforce the Minimum Necessary Rule. Audit Electronic Health Record (EHR) access logs regularly. Clearly communicate and enforce a Sanction Policy that includes immediate termination and potential criminal referral for unauthorized snooping.
8. Failure to Use the Minimum Necessary Standard
The Privacy Rule requires that when using or disclosing PHI, organziations must make reasonable efforts to limit the amount disclosed to the minimum necessary to achieve the purpose of the use or disclosure. Sending an entire medical chart when only a lab result is needed is a violation.
- The Mandate: The Minimum Necessary Standard (45 CFR § 164.502(b)).
- Prevention: Review all workflows for disclosures. Train staff to specifically ask: “Do I absolutely need to disclose this entire record, or will a summary suffice?”
9. Improper Disposal of PHI
This violation applies to the physical and digital destruction of PHI. Leaving paper charts in an open bin or failing to wipe the hard drive of an old server, copier, or scanner before disposal can lead to a costly breach.
- The Mandate: Physical Safeguards (45 CFR § 164.310(d)(2)) and Disposal (45 CFR § 164.524(c)(4)).
- Prevention: Implement a clear media disposal and re-use policy. Use certified shredding services for paper. Use secure, industry-standard wiping software (or physical destruction like degaussing/shredding) for all hard drives, flash drives, and other electronic media. Organizations must properly dispose of all media containing PHI.
10. Failure to Issue Timely Breach Notification
The Breach Notification Rule mandates a clear timeline for notifying affected individuals, the media (if over 500 individuals), and the OCR following the discovery of a breach of unsecured PHI. Failure to meet these deadlines exacerbates a violation and results in additional fines.
- The Mandate: The Breach Notification Rule (45 CFR § 164.400–414).
- Prevention: Develop a tested and documented Incident Response Plan and Contingency Plan. Be prepared to act immediately when a breach is discovered. The deadline is no later than 60 days after discovery, but notification should be sent without unreasonable delay.
- Government Resource: Use the HHS Breach Reporting Portal to report breaches of 500 or more individuals.
The Bottom Line: HIPAA Enforcement
HIPAA compliance is not a checkbox; it is a continuously evolving, and documented process. The pattern in OCR enforcement is clear: penalties are overwhelmingly issued for systemic failures in the fundamentals, not one-off mistakes.
To truly protect your organization from seven-figure fines, you must invest in the foundational requirements: a comprehensive, annual Risk Assessment and diligent vendor management.
Need help getting your compliance plan audit-ready? Explore Total HIPAA’s Solutions for Continuous Compliance.
